In this candid panel, Eric Weintraub is joined by Colin Mustful, Jillian Forsberg, and Alina Adams for a practical discussion on revision, research, beta readers, and the often-difficult judgment call of when a manuscript is ready to face the world.

Drawing on experience as authors, editor, and publisher, the panel explores the realities of preparing a historical fiction novel for submission:

• How to know when you’ve revised enough—or when you might be submitting too early

• Using beta readers, critique partners, editors, and subject experts effectively

• Handling new research discoveries late in the drafting process

• Balancing historical accuracy, emotional truth, and storytelling choices

• Final polish: proofreading, formatting, and sensitivity or expert feedback

• What publishers and agents look for in historical fiction submissions

• The emotional side of revision, confidence, and persistence

Whether you’re finishing your first historical novel or preparing your tenth, this session offers actionable guidance on recognizing when your manuscript is ready to leave your desk—and how to approach the submission process with clarity and confidence.