Don’t have a manuscript to submit but still want to be a Beta Reader? You can!
Manuscript Matchup
A Guided Beta Reader Program from History Through Fiction
A Structured Way to Get Feedback on Your Manuscript
Finding reliable beta readers can feel like a gamble. Manuscript Matchup takes the uncertainty out of the process by offering a structured, guided exchange facilitated by Colin Mustful, editor, publisher, and founder of History Through Fiction.
Each round is carefully managed by Colin, who creates the matches, provides guidance on how to give and receive effective critique, and checks in throughout the cycle to keep participants on track. For writers who want guaranteed professional feedback, the Premium Tier includes a direct manuscript review from Colin.
How It Works
Register Your Spot
Complete a short signup form with details about your manuscript (genre, style, preferences). Enrollment is capped at 15 participants each quarter.Receive Your Match
Colin pairs you with one or more compatible writers based on genre, goals, and feedback preferences.Learn How to Critique Effectively
After matches are sent, Colin shares an instructional video and resources on how to offer meaningful, constructive feedback.Stay on Track
Colin checks in during the cycle to encourage progress, answer questions, and ensure productive exchanges.Read, Review, and Exchange
Spend three months reading and critiquing manuscripts. Matched partners meet one-on-one at the end of the cycle to discuss feedback directly, with additional beta readers providing written responses as applicable.
Quarterly Enrollment • Limited to 15 Writers per Round • Register Now for January - March 2026
Why Manuscript Matchup?
✅ Guided Structure – matches are facilitated, lessons provided, and check-ins ensure accountability.
✅ Supportive Learning – resources on how to give and receive critique effectively.
✅ Flexible Participation – choose full exchanges or assigned readers.
✅ Professional Option – guaranteed expert feedback available with the Premium Tier.
✅ Limited Enrollment – only 15 writers per quarter, for a more manageable, attentive program.
Program Options & Pricing
Early-Bird Registration — $30
Available during the first two months of each enrollment period (e.g., October–November for the January–March cycle)Standard Registration — $45
Opens during the final month before the cycle begins (e.g., December for the January–March cycle).Re-Entry Incentive — 50% Off
Returning after making revisions? Save when you rejoin a future round.Premium Add-On — $50
Guaranteed professional feedback: Colin Mustful, HTF Founder and experienced editor, will review the first 50 pages of your manuscript. Can be added to any enrollment.
Join the Next Round
Manuscript Matchup is about more than trading manuscripts—it’s about learning how to give better feedback, receiving more useful critiques, and growing alongside other writers.
👉 Spots are limited—secure yours today!
